A close-up photo capturing a beautifully arranged display of various adorable stuffed animals, enticing potential buyers with their vibrant colors and irresistible charm.

Are you looking to declutter your home and make some extra cash by selling off your stuffed animal collection? With the right platform and strategy, selling stuffed animals can be surprisingly lucrative.

In this comprehensive guide, we’ll explore the 10 best places to sell stuffed animals for top dollar, from local consignment shops to major online marketplaces like eBay and Facebook.

Local Consignment and Resale Stores

Local consignment and resale stores offer great opportunities to sell your stuffed animals. These stores specialize in buying and selling gently used items from the local community. Here are some top options:

Kid to Kid

With over 140 franchise locations across North America, Kid to Kid buys and sells gently used children’s apparel, toys, books, and more. The items must be in good condition without rips, stains, or other damage.

Kid to Kid accepts a wide variety of stuffed animals including beanie babies, Webkinz, Squishmallows, and more. You’ll earn 45-65% of the selling price in cash or store credit.

Once Upon a Child

Once Upon a Child has over 425 stores nationwide focused on more affordable children’s items. They buy and sell quality used clothing, shoes, toys, books, baby gear, and stuffed animals in clean, working condition. Popular brands like Ty, Gund, Aurora, and classic characters are accepted.

You can earn 30-60% of the selling price in cash or store credit.

Clothes Mentor

While mainly focused on women’s fashion, some Clothes Mentor locations also buy and sell children’s items including select stuffed animals. The company has over 140 franchise stores. Stuffed animals should be popular name brands in excellent condition.

Payment is typically 35-60% of the selling price in cash or store credit.

Plato’s Closet

Plato’s Closet buys and sells gently used apparel and accessories for teens and young adults. Some locations may consider buying certain stuffed animals that would appeal to this demographic, like anime characters, Squishmallows, and classic characters.

With over 600 locations, it’s worth checking with your local store. Payout is usually 30-50% in cash.

The great thing about consignment and resale stores is you don’t have to handle meeting up with buyers, shipping items, etc. Just bring in your quality stuffed animals and the stores take care of the rest. It’s an easy way to declutter and earn a little extra cash too!

eBay

Huge buyer base

With over 159 million active buyers globally as of 2020, eBay has an enormously vast base of potential customers for your stuffed animals (source). This massive marketplace allows you to get your listings in front of millions of motivated shoppers from over 190 countries.

Moreover, over 1.5 billion items are listed on eBay at any given time, meaning buyers flock to the site knowing their odds of finding what they want are high.

Easy listing process

eBay makes listing stuffed animals incredibly straightforward. Their user-friendly selling platform allows you to quickly upload images and descriptions for your items. Helpful features like preset shipping rates and listing templates further simplify the process.

Best of all, listing fees are extremely affordable, with most basic listings completely free up to 50 items per month.

Option for auction-style pricing

While you can use fixed pricing for your stuffed animals, eBay also gives the option to sell via auctions. This opens the door for buyers to competitively bid on your items. Auctions build excitement and spike demand thanks to the urgency of limited listing timeframes.

Ultimately, an auction’s final sold price comes down to how much buyers are willing to pay. With the right product and some luck, you could earn way beyond expectations. What stuffed critter collector wouldn’t relish the chance to snag a rare find in a bidding war?

Pros Cons
  • Access to vast buyer base
  • Easy account setup
  • Minimal fees
  • High competition
  • Fee for promoted listings
  • Processing time for payments

While extremely popular, eBay’s gigantic marketplace comes with fierce competition. Stand out from the crowd by taking professional photos, writing robust descriptions, and leveraging promotions. With quality merchandise and compelling listings, your cute and cuddly stuffed pals can charmingly make you money on eBay.

Facebook Marketplace

Sell locally

Facebook Marketplace allows you to sell your stuffed animals locally to buyers in your area. This is a great option if you don’t want to deal with packing and shipping items. You can meet potential buyers in a public place to complete the transaction safely.

No fees

Unlike selling on sites like eBay or Etsy, Facebook Marketplace does not charge any selling fees or commissions. That means you keep all of the profit from your stuffed animal sales. With existing shipping costs being so high right now, avoiding extra fees is a major benefit.

Leverage existing network

Most people already use Facebook regularly to connect with friends and family. This gives sellers a built-in audience of potential buyers. You can share your marketplace listings easily with your existing Facebook connections.

People may be more inclined to buy from someone they already know through social media.

According to Oberlo’s statistics, the Facebook Marketplace sees over 1 billion monthly active users. With that kind of reach, you’ll have plenty of people who could discover and purchase your stuffed animals locally.

Mercari

Mercari is a popular peer-to-peer selling app that makes it easy to sell your unwanted items, including stuffed animals. With over 20 million active users and $1 billion in sales per year, Mercari provides a huge potential customer base for your plush pals. 🧸

One of the best things about selling on Mercari is that listing items is completely free. You simply download the app, take a photo of your item, add a description, set your asking price, and you’re good to go. Mercari only takes a 10% selling fee once your stuffed animal sells.

Mercari shoppers actively browse the app searching for great deals, so pricing your stuffed animals competitively is important. Checking completed listings for similar items can give you an idea of reasonable asking prices.

Well-loved plushies tend to sell between $5-$15, while hot ticket stuffed animals like Squishmallows or Jellycats can fetch $20-$50+.

To attract buyers browsing Mercari, use enticing listing titles like “Jumbo 20” Squishmallow Narwhal Plush SUPER RARE,” detailed descriptions noting any defects, and clear, well-lit photos showing all angles.

Share what makes your stuffed critter special to connect with potential buyers on an emotional level. 🥰

Once your stuffed animal sells, Mercari emails you a prepaid shipping label to securely send off your sold item. As long as your plush arrives safely and as described, you’ll receive your earnings in your bank account within a few days.

With its huge user base, simple selling process, and low fees, Mercari is undoubtedly one of the best places to sell your pre-loved stuffed animals. List your plushes today and watch your unwanted stuffies become someone else’s cuddly companion. 👍

Poshmark

Poshmark is an online marketplace where people buy and sell new or used items from each other. It has become a popular place for sellers to make extra money by listing their unwanted stuff. If you have a collection of stuffed animals you no longer want, Poshmark can be a great platform to sell them and declutter your home.

Poshmark makes selling incredibly easy. You simply need to take photos of your stuffed animals, write descriptions, set prices, and ship the sold items to buyers. The app offers shipping labels and packaging so you don’t have to worry about logistics.

Poshmark also takes a small commission from each of your sales.

When listing stuffed animals on Poshmark, excellent photos are key to making sales. Take pictures in bright natural light against a clean, solid background. Capture any tags showing the brand or license details. Write detailed descriptions of the materials, size, condition, etc.

If there are any flaws, always disclose them upfront to avoid returns. Research sold listings for comparable items to price yours fairly.

Stuffed animals in new or like-new condition tend to get the highest prices on Poshmark. Vintage toys and rare collectibles can also command premium pricing from serious collectors. Even well-loved stuffed animals can sell if priced low enough. Make sure to note any defects in your descriptions.

To boost exposure for your stuffed animal listings, follow other Poshmark sellers and share your items on social media. Engaging with potential customers by commenting, hosting giveaways, etc can also help drive traffic. Poshmark rewards active sellers by placing them higher in search results.

Etsy

Etsy is one of the most popular online marketplaces for selling handmade, vintage, or craft supplies. With over 60 million active buyers searching Etsy every month, it offers an amazing opportunity to sell stuffed animals to a huge global audience.

Setting up an Etsy shop to sell stuffed animals is easy and only takes a few minutes. You simply need to create an account, choose a unique shop name, list your bank account details to receive payments, and pay a small $0.20 listing fee per item.

Once your shop is ready, snapping some high-quality product photos is key. Ensure you capture all angles in bright, natural light against a clean background. Write compelling titles and descriptions highlighting materials used and key features.

Etsy buyers love handmade uniqueness so be sure to emphasize this. You can also share your creative process and story behind each stuffed animal in your descriptions to connect with buyers.

When pricing your stuffed animals, research what similar items sell for then competitively price yours. Etsy takes a 5% transaction fee when you make a sale as well as a 3% + $0.25 payment processing fee. You can account for these fees when pricing items.

To attract buyers, utilize all 13 tag allowances per listing. Include relevant keywords that buyers would be searching e.g. “stuffed bear”, “plush lion”, “handmade stuffed animal” etc. Refresh your listings frequently to keep them appearing at the top of search results.

Share your shop link and listings on your social media channels to increase exposure.

As your Etsy shop grows, 97% of buyers say they would return to purchase again from sellers who provide excellent customer service. Respond to buyer enquiries promptly, communicate shipping timeframes accurately, and resolve any issues ASAP.

This will earn you glowing 5 star reviews which build credibility and trust in your shop.

Selling stuffed animals on Etsy can become a very lucrative business. Top Etsy sellers make over $100,000 per year from their crafts. With some beautiful stuffed animal designs that customers love, excellent marketing, and great customer service, you could be well on your way!

Craigslist

Craigslist is a great online platform to sell your used stuffed animals locally. You can create listings for free and reach buyers in your city looking for toys for their kids or collectors looking for rare plushies. Some tips for selling stuffed animals successfully on Craigslist:

  • Take good quality photos that show any tags or branding on the plushies as well as condition details
  • Research comparable prices for the brands/characters you are selling so you can price them appropriately
  • Write detailed descriptions about the size, condition, any flaws, etc to set proper expectations
  • Consider offering bundles or deals on multiple items to increase interest
  • Meet potential buyers in a safe, public place like a coffee shop instead of your home address

The advantage of Craigslist is that you can often sell toys for more than you would make selling to a thrift store or toy resale store, and you don’t have to pack and ship anything. It’s a convenient way to unload items from your own collection or make some money off toys and plushies your kids have outgrown.

OfferUp

OfferUp is one of the most popular apps and websites for selling locally. With over 90 million downloads, it has a huge user base looking to buy secondhand items in their area. This makes it a great platform to sell your stuffed animal collection quickly.

How to Sell on OfferUp

Selling on OfferUp is quite straightforward. First, you need to download the app or access the website and create an account. Make sure to add a profile picture for some authenticity.

Next, tap the “Post a Listing” button and select the toys and games category, then stuffed animals. Give your listing an eye-catching title and upload several clear photos showing any tags or markings on your stuffed animals. The description should include details like sizes, condition (e.g.

great condition with minimal wear), brands, etc. You can select local pickup or shipment.

Buyers will start contacting you shortly with questions or offers! You can negotiate pricing through OfferUp’s messaging system. Once agreed, arrange a public meeting spot or coordinate shipment.

Tips for Success

Here are some tips to help your stuffed animal listings stand out and sell faster on OfferUp:

  • Price competitively based on current rates for similar items
  • Post plushies in bundles or lots to attract bulk buyers
  • Refresh your listings frequently to get more visibility
  • Answer buyer questions promptly and confirm meetups/shipping
  • Build up your profile with positive reviews to establish trustworthiness

Benefits of Selling on OfferUp

There are several advantages to using OfferUp for selling stuffed toys:

  • Large local audience – ability to sell faster
  • Free to list unlimited items with no subscription fees
  • In-app messaging and seamless transactions
  • Relatively safe meetings coordinated through the app

As of March 2022, OfferUp reported having over 56 million active users per month in the U.S. alone. With this huge built-in audience of local buyers, your stuffed animals are highly likely to sell within days or weeks. The app continues to grow in popularity for secondhand goods.

Just make sure to price competitively, post great descriptions and photos, and be responsive to interested buyers. You’ll quickly establish a solid selling track record, earn great reviews, and have a new go-to marketplace for clearing out plushies while earning extra cash.

Letgo

Letgo is a popular peer-to-peer selling app that makes it easy to sell used items locally. With over 100 million downloads, it has a huge user base of buyers looking for great deals. This makes Letgo a potentially lucrative venue for selling stuffed animals and plush toys.

To get started selling on Letgo, simply download the app, take pictures of your items, add descriptions, and list them for sale. Make sure stuffed animals are clean and undamaged to fetch higher prices. Take clear, well-lit photos to show any defects and capture the colors accurately.

In the description, mention details like the size, brand, any special features, and general condition. Research prices for comparable items so you can competitively price yours. List items for free, and Letgo takes a small cut when you make a sale.

Letgo has search features so buyers can find exactly what they want. Use relevant keywords in titles and descriptions so stuffed animals show up in searches. Words like “stuffed animal”, “plush”, “Beanie Babies”, brands like “Ty”, characters like “Pokemon”, etc. can help attract interested buyers.

Letgo allows buyers to message sellers through the app and arrange local pickups. This means quick sales without hefty shipping costs. Meet in safe public locations, and accept payment via Letgo’s secure payment processing, cash, or other methods.

With savvy pricing, smart keywords, clear photos, and fair descriptions, selling stuffed animals on Letgo can be rewarding. Its vast user base and local meetups make it easy to move quality plush toys and command good value.

Garage Sales

Garage sales can be a great place to sell your unwanted stuffed animals and make some extra cash. Setting up a garage sale takes a bit of work, but the payoff can be worth it. Here are some tips for maximizing your stuffed animal sales at your next garage sale:

Price to Sell

When pricing your stuffed animals, it’s better to price them to sell rather than trying to get top dollar. 💰 Garage sale shoppers love finding great deals, so price your stuffed animals attractively. A good rule of thumb is to price them at 10-30% of their original retail value.

You can bundle together stuffed animals that go together for an even better deal.

Display Creatively

Get creative with how you display your stuffed animals! Grouping similar plushies together can create a cute vignette that attracts buyers. You can set up play areas with dollhouses or make a stuffed animal arcade. Use baskets, shelves, and furniture you already own to show them off.

The cuter the display, the more shoppers it will draw in!

Advertise Widely

Spread the word about your upcoming garage sale to drive traffic. Post flyers around town, create event listings on sites like Craigslist and Facebook Marketplace, and ask friends to help promote it. You can even offer stuffed animal giveaways leading up to the sale to create buzz.

Driving engagement on social media with cute pics of your plushies for sale can also help attract stuffed animal fans.

Selling stuffed animals at your garage sale allows you to clear out toys and make some extra money at the same time. 💸 With the right pricing, display, and promotion, your unwanted plushies can be turned into cash for your next adventure!

Conclusion

Selling off stuffed animals that you or your kids have outgrown can be a savvy way to make extra money and free up some space. The key is finding the right marketplace for your particular items where you can get maximum visibility and fair pricing.

We recommend trying a few of the options above like consignment stores, Facebook Marketplace, eBay, and Craigslist to compare which brings in the most profit and interests for the specific stuffed animals you’re looking to sell.

With smart pricing, clear photos and descriptions, plus a little patience, you can effectively tap into the thriving secondary market for toys and stuffed animals.

Similar Posts